In a nutshell: My classroom full of black, brown, East Asian, South Asian, orthodox Jewish, Muslim, female, and gay male students, very few of whom are well spoken for by the White Male Christian Subject of Culture, have a very hard time accepting the idea that they themselves have supplanted him.
This semester I have been teaching a class at Brooklyn College called The Idea of Character in the Western Literary Tradition. The course description, not of my own design, is very broad, and allows the instructor to cobble together any kind of survey of Western literary texts that suits his or her fancy.
I decided to go broad and teach the class as a survey of the entire Western literary tradition from Homer to Toni Morrison. I wanted to explore the emergence of the idea of Western Civilization itself and its eventual run in with the crises of multiculturalism and globalization. In the course of the semester I came up with the idea of a White Male Christian Subject of Culture who imagined himself to have roots in twin Greco-Roman and Judeo-Christian traditions. We looked at the Greek male heroic subject of culture in the Homeric epics and how he was joined on the literary landscape by a range of alternative "heroes" (in the later sense of protagonist or central figure), including the idealized shepherd of bucolic poetry, the parodic antihero of Hellenistic mime, and the indignant scowl of Roman satire. We also looked at representations of women's voices (albeit in poems by men), with examples including the Briseis and Penelope of Ovid's Heroides and the gossipy housewives of Herodas's sixth mime. I took particular pleasure in regaling my students with ancient literary examples of pimps, prostitutes, hustlers, and sex-toy mongers. They enjoyed reading these texts and, more importantly from a pedagogical perspective, they were surprised by them, and learned some new things about the Western literary tradition.
By the end of the semester (this week), I was trying to convince them that Western Civilization was over, a historical construct that now exists only as a relic of the past, not the dominant form of culture (to use Raymond Williams' term) or the discourse (to go Foucaultian) in which we currently live. One last, great, impotent tirade of the White Male Christian Subject of Western Culture, I have argued to them, can be heard in Dostoyevksy's Underground Man (Notes from Underground), and his last pitiful gasps can be heard in T.S. Eliot's "The Lovesong of J. Alfred Prufrock." Toni Morrison's Sula represents a radically different form of cultural existence, with its defiant assertion of black female subjectivity that is not only aware of its historical marginalization but determined to assert both its own dignity and its right to speak.
I was shocked, but not surprised, and in fact perversely pleased, to find in class yesterday that The End of Western Civilization was a very hard sell in my classroom full of black, brown, East Asian, South Asian, orthodox Jewish, Muslim, female, and gay male students, very few of whom are well spoken for by the White Male Christian Subject of Culture, but all of whom had a very hard time accepting the idea that they themselves had supplanted him.
That is the exciting discovery I wanted to share with you in this post. As old friends of Pedagogishness might be aware, this post marks an emergence from a four-month silence on my part. The academic year 2011-2012 was exhausting, somewhat traumatizing, and left me voiceless. It's been a rough fall semester, but also exciting, and my voice is starting to come back. This semester has given me a lot to think about and write about, and as it runs its course in final exams and the posting of grades, I believe readers of Pedagogishness will have more to demand their attention.
I think you'll find all those White Male Christian Subjects of Culture cloistered in Seattle in January. --HeatherReplyDelete
For those not in the know, Dr. Vincent is referring to the annual meeting of the American Philological Association, this year taking place in Seattle. And my reply to Heather's comment: Indeed!!!ReplyDelete
F*ck the West, let's go East!ReplyDelete
Trắng da có nhiều phương pháp , nhưng hầu hết mọi người điều sử dụng các loại thuốc trắng da nhưng đặt ra nhiều câu hỏi quanh các loại thuốc này như thuốc uống trắng da nào hiệu quả , thuốc uống trắng da ivory caps có hại không , thuốc uống trắng da ivory caps có tốt không ? Đó là một vài câu hỏi liên quan đến thuốc làm trăng da ivory caps , cùng tìm hiểu nhé . Ngoài trắng da thì mỹ phẩm sakura nhật bản còn giúp da giữ được nét tự nhiên và chống lão hóa vì dùng kem chống lão hóa sakura , ngoài làm trắng da thì còn là kem chống nắng tốt nhất và giá cả thì cũng là vấn đề vì vậy có nhiều câu hỏi như kem chống nắng neutrogena giá bao nhiêu ,.. Có nhiều loại nên có nhiều giá khác nhau . Nếu gót chân bị nứt nẻ thì nên dùng kem trị nứt gót chân neutrogena foot cream sẽ giúp bạn có được bàn chân đẹp như ý.ReplyDelete
Hiện nay có nhiều cách trang điểm và địa điểm dạy cách trang điểm tốt như dịch vụ trang điểm cô dâu tại hcm, dạy trang điểm tại nhà thì nên sử dụng bộ mỹ phẩm trang điểm cơ bản. Khi trang điểm thì bạn nên sử dụng các sản phẩm trang điểm như mỹ phẩm trang điểm shiseido, mỹ phẩm trang điểm maybeline và khó nhất trong trang điểm là cách trang điểm cho mắt một mí, hy vọng sẽ giúp bạn có được cách trang điểm hiệu quả và tốt nhất.ReplyDelete